Can antimicrobial fabric stop the spread of viruses? It’s not a new question, but it has been dragged to the forefront of many minds as we watch the novel coronavirus, COVID-19, sweep across the world.
The practice of using specific materials on various surfaces to prevent the buildup and spread of germs has a long history. In ancient Egypt, spices and herbs were used on burial dressings for mummification. Bamboo with antimicrobial properties was used for building in China, and up through the 19th century, copper pots and brass door knobs were common, whether or not our ancestors understood precisely the benefits of these materials.
Around World War II, it became common to apply various substances and chemical treatments to fabrics for truck covers, uniforms, and other textiles to prevent the growth of microbes like mold, mildew, and bacteria, while keeping fabrics clean and strong, although those treatments often came with little regard to the health and environmental effects of their application.
Today, technologies related to antimicrobial textiles are incredibly varied and increasingly eco-friendly. However, in discussion of the use of antimicrobials to prevent the spread of disease, particularly in relation to the spread of COVID-19, it’s important to understand what antimicrobial fabrics can and cannot do.
First, let’s take a look at what antimicrobial fabric is.
Antimicrobial fabric is fabric treated with or infused with one or several of a variety of substances to keep microbes such as bacteria, fungi, and viruses from flourishing within its fibers. This is particularly important, as the porous surfaces of textiles tend to hold in moisture and heat, especially when close to the human body, which makes an environment that is exceptionally conducive to the growth of microorganisms.
A single bacteria cell, in the right situation, can multiply to over a million in the span of just 8 hours without intervention. Unchecked microbes can lead to infections in those with prolonged close contact with contaminated fabric and the spread of pathogenic disease, as well as deterioration of the strength of the fibers, so prevention of their growth is highly important.
Antimicrobial fabric is used in healthcare, primarily for bed dressings, drapery, and gowns, so that said textiles don’t become contaminated and need to be replaced as often. It is also used in filters, packaging, and uniforms in countless other industries.
That said, antimicrobial fabric is not a material that kills all germs on contact.
Even the fastest acting antimicrobial fabrics can take up to ten minutes to kill many microbes, and those are just one end of a spectrum of results that are all labeled ‘antimicrobial’. Some fabrics merely slow or stop the growth of germs without killing them, while others may kill a percentage of germs over time.
In terms of availability, the vast majority of fabrics, particularly fashion fabrics, marketed to the public as antimicrobial fall into the ‘slowing or stopping growth’ portion of the spectrum. They’re meant for use in athleticwear, and they’re great at it, as they prevent moisture buildup that starts to smell. When paired with moisture-wicking material, you’ve got the perfect material to keep you and your clothes feeling cleaner and smelling better through a long, sweaty workout.
However, a mask made of the average antimicrobial fabric is no more effective against coronavirus than a mask of any other fabric, and depending on the density of the weave of the fabric, may even be less effective than a mask of, say, a tightly woven cotton.
That said, specialty fabrics infused with zinc and copper oxides or silver ions have been proven effective in destroying viruses, particularly lipid-enveloped viruses like coronavirus. These fabrics, however, are still in the early stages of production, primarily in Switzerland and Israel, and the companies producing them are directing them to the production of personal protective equipment for healthcare professionals. As the need for PPE increases, it’s unlikely that we’ll see them available for public use in the near future.
So, there have recently been many improvements in antimicrobial fabrics for preventing the spread of disease, particularly in a healthcare setting, but the use of antimicrobial fabrics is not a substitute for good hygiene and social distancing.
14 comments
Thank you so much for this article. I happen to have a textiles science degree from UC Davis. Everything written here is spot on!
Thank you for explaining! I was looking into mask that say they are antimicrobial and that’s how I got to his page. I was a wondering what is your take on mask that are on sale right now claiming to be “self-sterilizing ” and “antimicrobial such as this one https://ouragami.org/products/oura-air-mask?variant=31892966735943
Unfortunately I’d be a little wary. It looks like it may kill germs, but it likely wouldn’t do much against the virus itself. That said though, if it still does its filtering job, it does do a bit more work than other masks. 🙂
I found this while searching about the Sonovia masks (yes they are made in Israel) and since you did mention them, but said they’re still far away from being available but this was back in April…. I’d love to near your opinion on them now! I mean, are they REALLY worth the $$$?? Is it REALLY safe to wash them only every three days (eewww?)
Thanks!
Hi Anne!
Would you be interested to consult with us on a project we are undertaking?
Regards, Gary Price
I would be very interested in your opinion on a similiar topic. Could I pick your brain? If you admit mind helping me with something my email is [email protected]
I am trying to study the effectiveness of antimicrobial treatments on vinyl textiles to be used in office furniture applications. It appears they are relatively ineffective. Am I correct in that assumption?
This is a great article. Thank you for enlightening us. It can be a huge risk if people are misinformed or even mistaken.
Thank you for explaining the misconception !
Picky comment, but viruses are not microbes. Other than that, it’s refreshing to see a lay article about COVID-19 with factual information. Your fashions and fabrics are spectacular.
Ms. Wilson, I have never replied to someones comments before but I felt compelled to send something because I did not want to detract from the positive impact this article made. My comment is a picky comment as well, but your picky comment is inaccurate…and, in my opinion, more than a little condescending. This is a sewing site. I am more than impressed by the knowledgeable and accurate information the author shared. Given the amount of misinformation out there, this author showed she did her due diligence and research prior to writing this article. I appreciate her effort and would feel confident in her accuracy in other articles. Thank you, Ms. Veneziale, for going the extra mile on this. Your article saved lives, it educated me enough to reconsider my confidence in and planned use of antimicrobial fabrics.
“…Microorganisms or microbes are microscopic organisms that exist as unicellular, multicellular, or cell clusters. Microorganims are widespread in nature and are beneficial to life, but some can cause serious harm. They can be divided into six major types: bacteria, archaea, fungi, protozoa, algae, and viruses.Aug 14, 2020…” https://bio.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Microbiology/Book%3A_Microbiology_(Boundless)/1%3A_Introduction_to_Microbiology/1.2%3A_Microbes_and_the_World/1.2A_Types_of_Microorganisms
Thank you for your article. I was just thinking about using moisture-wicking fabric from an old t-shirt of mine but decided to see if anyone had any thoughts or inputs on the matter. And it just so happened that you did and for that, thank you again and stay safe out there people!
Ok but I want a mask that wont cause my face to break out. Im assuming using anti-microbial fabric for face masks, follows the same principal as using Anti-microbial pillow cases, does it not?
Hi Nik, you can find information about anti-microbial fabric here. 🙂